What are the risks of the algorithm being fed by user complaints?

[hasinam2206]

The fear of the sector is clear: if this tool is made to report the use of bad practices, it means that they abound. How does Google guarantee that the person filling out the form does so in good faith, and is not the competition trying to lower our page in searches? Worse still, are not the users who manipulate the algorithm to "rank" better (the same ones that Google intends to punish with this measure) the ones who have a greater motivation to complete the form in search of reporting and worsening the positioning of others? You are not going to pretend that while you were reading about this possibility you were not thinking of doing this same thing. It is not clear, is this an update for people who want to improve their search, or are they giving a new weapon to those who look for shortcuts so that they can fight in SEO against those who do their job well?

This is the real danger that this new feature malaysia mobile database brings. Especially since Google has not specified what criteria it intends to implement when analyzing complaints, nor how it will process them. Initially, it stated its intention to treat each complaint individually, even providing personal feedback to the complainant's email. Will this be the case, or will the email be the classic automated response? Faced with a wave of reports that may arrive as soon as this new feature is implemented, it is difficult to imagine that the technology giant would be willing to allocate the necessary human resources to prioritize and categorize these complaints. Will it process them with some system assisted by artificial intelligence?

It would be the most logical thing to do, but if they do it this way, can they guarantee that they won't end up punishing the wrong users? The lack of clarification from Google regarding what actions it will take based on the forms, or how it will penalize the reported pages brings us more uncertainty than certainty. The lack of clarity suggests that there is no guarantee that these practices will not happen.